Finance Daily
Thursday, 05 November 2026
Commodities

ETMarkets Commodity Talk| A 10% allocation to gold and silver? Motilal Oswal's Manav Modi explains the commodity playbook

Investors are currently faced with the challenge of navigating significant discrepancies in commodity markets and determining whether to allocate a portion of their portfolios to these assets. The questions at hand include whether to buy during price dips, capitalize on rallies, or adopt a more cautious approach. In a recent discussion on ETMarkets Commodity Talk, Manav Modi, a Commodities Analyst at Motilal Oswal Financial Services, analyzed the differing trends in gold, crude oil, and copper. He also offered insights into the long-term role of commodities in investment portfolios, common pitfalls to avoid, and the rationale for considering a minimum allocation of 10% to gold and silver, depending on an investor's risk tolerance and investment timeline.

Modi noted that October has seen stark divergences in commodity prices, driven by varying market reactions to geopolitical risks, inflation, and interest rates. He explained that concerns surrounding supply due to the conflict in Iran and elevated oil prices have buoyed crude oil and certain industrial metals. Conversely, copper is experiencing a complex scenario, balancing long-term demand for electrification against immediate worries about growth, US stockpiling, and the pace of investments related to artificial intelligence.

As for gold, which has dipped below the $4,000-per-ounce threshold while crude oil has surged, Modi attributed this to a mix of factors, primarily geopolitical events influencing inflation and expectations surrounding interest rates. He indicated that the increase in risk premium and supply disruptions have supported oil prices, reviving concerns about persistent inflation, which in turn has kept US interest rates and the dollar strong. This environment has negatively impacted gold's appeal as a safe haven, particularly as profit-taking followed its previous strong performance. The Federal Reserve's decision on October 28 to maintain interest rates, with two dissenting votes advocating for a hike, further emphasizes the market's sensitivity to potential tightening policies.

Despite copper's essential role in electrification and infrastructure, its recent price decline has raised questions about whether it presents a buying opportunity or signals a slowdown in global industrial demand. Modi suggested that while the correction warrants a reassessment of expectations, it does not necessarily indicate a broad downturn in industrial demand. He noted that copper's price surge had been fueled by production cuts, significant supply shortages, and stockpiling in the US ahead of possible tariffs, as well as optimism regarding AI data centers. However, recent caution regarding AI investments and arbitrage between the London Metal Exchange and the Chicago Mercantile Exchange have influenced pricing. Additionally, rising premiums and decreasing inventories in China indicate mixed physical demand and supply conditions. For long-term investors, the decision to invest depends on pricing and investment horizon, although near-term signals remain uncertain.

Modi elaborated on how higher interest rates impact gold, crude oil, and copper differently. He explained that rising rates typically exert downward pressure on gold by increasing the opportunity cost of holding a non-yielding asset and supporting the dollar. In contrast, crude oil does not have a straightforward inverse relationship with interest rates, as supply disruptions can elevate prices even in a tighter policy environment. Copper, being more sensitive to financing costs and expectations in construction and manufacturing, can see its demand outlook negatively affected by high rates. The distinct drivers of demand, risks to supply, and sensitivities of these commodities highlight why they should not be viewed as a single asset class.

Looking ahead, Modi suggested that even if the Fed maintains rates without an immediate hike, gold could still remain under pressure if the market anticipates tighter policies in the future. He pointed out that the Fed's recent decision to hold its target range at 3.75%–4% was coupled with a warning that inflation remains high, and two policymakers dissented in favor of increasing rates. Should investors believe that rates may rise or stay elevated longer, it could keep US yields and the dollar strong, further weighing on gold prices. A mere pause in rate hikes may not bolster gold unless inflation data or Fed communications signal a shift in expectations.

To determine if the sharp correction in gold is a healthy adjustment rather than the start of a prolonged decline, Modi indicated that he would be looking for signs of easing selling pressure and stability in US yields and the dollar. Furthermore, a drop in oil prices that alleviates inflation concerns, along with less aggressive Fed expectations, could improve the outlook for gold. Continued demand from central banks and ETFs might also provide a fundamental support layer. Conversely, repeated failures to rebound, rising yields, and a stronger dollar could suggest that the correction is deepening.

When it comes to retail investors considering commodities, Modi recommends viewing them as a distinct allocation within a diversified portfolio. He highlighted that while commodities can provide diversification benefits, their prices are often volatile, influenced by factors such as weather, geopolitical events, and inventory levels. A thoughtful allocation could be appropriate for investors who possess the necessary knowledge, risk tolerance, and investment timeframe.

Modi cautioned against common mistakes that retail investors make when engaging with commodities, particularly during sharp rallies or corrections. He noted that many investors chase rallies due to fear of missing out, incorrectly assume that falling prices make an asset cheap, and often over-invest in a single commodity. In the case of futures trading, leverage can amplify losses, and costs associated with expiry and rollover can impact returns even when the overall market outlook is favorable.