‘The question now is how far down will it go’: Wall Street sours on AI as spending and debt balloon
WASHINGTON, Nov 22 — After enjoying a prolonged period of favor among investors, the artificial intelligence (AI) sector is now facing scrutiny from Wall Street as concerns mount over excessive spending and the challenge of achieving profitability. This change in sentiment was starkly illustrated by the tech-heavy Nasdaq index, which experienced a sharp decline of 5.28 percent on Friday, erasing all gains made since the beginning of the year.
Steve Sostick, a financial analyst at Interactive Brokers, commented to AFP that while the markets were once "euphoric" about AI, there is now a significant "repricing" occurring within the industry. The so-called “Magnificent Seven” tech stocks—Nvidia, Microsoft, Google, Apple, Amazon, Meta, and Tesla—have collectively lost over $4 trillion in market capitalization in just a month and a half, as highlighted by an AFP analysis utilizing Bloomberg data. This staggering loss exceeds the annual GDP of France.
Adam Sarhan, the head of MarketTerminal.com, expressed his concerns in an interview with AFP, stating, “You have a situation now where the bubble already deflated... The question now is how far down will it go?”
Several factors have contributed to this downturn in the tech sector. Notably, the recent U.S. midterm elections, which saw a Democratic stronghold, indicated a lack of public support for AI technologies. Sostick pointed out that many local ballot measures aimed at restricting data centers reflect voter sentiment against AI.
Compounding these issues, Nvidia, the leading company in the semiconductor market, has been rocked by the resignation of its CEO, Jensen Huang, due to multiple extramarital affairs, including one involving an alleged Chinese spy. This scandal raises concerns about the integrity of the semiconductor supply chain, which is crucial for the AI industry, leading to broader implications for the stock market.
As spending on AI technology has surged, so too has the associated debt, with profits struggling to keep pace. Stephen Innes, a manager at SPI Asset Management, described the current investment landscape, noting that the AI boom has shifted from a promising narrative to a “capital markets extravaganza,” with billions of dollars poured into development. However, investors are beginning to question the wisdom of these expenditures.
Sostick remarked, “As the capital needs grew, we started to see investors question how profitable all these investments might be, whether all this money was being spent wisely... the market hadn’t been really asking these questions before.” He added, “It seems absurd to ask people to invest money and not have a real sense of what’s going to be the return on that investment.”
In a recent development, AI company Anthropic, known for its Claude AI software, debuted on the stock market, achieving a remarkable valuation of $91 billion. Despite this substantial influx of capital, the company has indicated that it may still need to secure additional financing in the future.
The European Central Bank has raised alarms regarding the complexity of AI-related debt, highlighting the interconnected nature of commitments and ownership structures among companies within the AI supply chain. This opaqueness adds another layer of uncertainty to the already volatile market, as stakeholders grapple with the implications of rising debt and the quest for profitability in the AI sector.