Finance Daily
Friday, 20 November 2026
Investing

Two 64-Year-Olds Each Earn $40,000 From the Same Wells as Oil Falls 13% in a Week: the Royalty Owner Keeps Every Social Security Check, While the Working-Interest Partner Gives Up $7,220

Two 64-year-old neighbors in an oil-rich region have both earned $40,000 this year from the same set of oil wells. One of them inherited the mineral rights and receives royalty payments, while the other purchased a working interest, meaning he owns a portion of the operation and is responsible for covering a share of the drilling and lease expenses. Both individuals opted to claim Social Security benefits early and are now facing a decline in oil prices.

The recent drop in oil prices has been significant. West Texas Intermediate, the benchmark for U.S. crude oil, fell from $110 per barrel on October 19 to $90 by November 11, with current prices lingering around $80. Economists are preparing for a potential global oversupply of oil, which will likely lead to reduced income for both neighbors. However, only one of them will experience a decrease in Social Security payments next year, primarily due to the way their incomes are categorized.

The royalty owner is unaffected by the earnings test that applies to Social Security benefits because this test does not consider royalties as self-employment income. In contrast, the working-interest partner’s earnings are classified as self-employment income, which means that he will face deductions in his Social Security benefits based on his income level.

For individuals who claim Social Security before reaching their full retirement age (FRA)—which is 67 for those born in 1960 or later—the earnings test can significantly impact benefits. The earnings test includes wages and profits from self-employment but does not account for investment income, such as royalties from mineral rights.

As a result, the working-interest partner, despite earning the same amount as his neighbor, will see a reduction of approximately $7,000 in his Social Security benefits for the year 2027. This reduction occurs because the earnings test penalizes him for his self-employment income while leaving the royalty owner’s benefits intact.

While the working-interest owner will eventually receive a recalibrated, higher monthly benefit once he reaches full retirement age, the immediate loss of income can be significant. Additionally, as oil prices continue to fluctuate, he may need to adjust his earnings estimates to prevent further withholding of benefits.

Although both neighbors are affected by the decline in oil prices, their financial situations diverge because of the differing classifications of their incomes. The royalty owner retains all of his Social Security payments, but the working-interest partner faces a 15.3% self-employment tax on his profits, which further complicates his financial planning.

Tax implications also play a role; while royalty income can trigger taxes on Social Security benefits, the working-interest partner's earnings are subject to additional self-employment taxes. For those in similar situations, it may be more advantageous to delay claiming Social Security until reaching full retirement age, as early claim reductions are permanent and can substantially affect lifetime benefits.

For individuals navigating these complexities, resources like "The Definitive Guide to Retirement Income" can offer valuable insights. This free guide, provided by Fisher Investments, addresses the real costs of retirement, potential income sources, and the mathematics of withdrawals to ensure funds last throughout retirement. Understanding these elements is crucial for making informed decisions regarding Social Security and overall retirement planning.