A Retiree With $500,000 in Schwab Investments Tries to Sell During a Market Slide and Finds the Website Locked Out. Another 2% Drop Could Cost Him $10,000
A retiree with a $500,000 investment in a Charles Schwab (NYSE:SCHW) 401(k) faced a critical situation recently when he attempted to sell his equity funds amid a market downturn. On November 17, as stock prices began to slide, he logged into his account only to find the website inaccessible due to a service outage. By 10:20 a.m. ET, over 1,400 reports of issues had been logged on Downdetector, and the service was restored approximately 18 minutes later.
This outage coincided with a turbulent period in the stock market, as investors braced for a significant week of technology earnings reports and a high-profile initial public offering in the artificial intelligence sector. The Volatility Index (VIX), which measures market fear, had climbed to 28 on November 5 before settling back to 19.
The retiree's concern was justified; a further 2% decline in his account balance would equate to a $10,000 loss on paper. However, the technical difficulties he faced may have inadvertently prevented him from making a more costly error by selling at a low point.
It's important to understand that moving funds within a 401(k) plan—such as shifting from stock investments to a stable value or money market option—does not trigger any tax consequences. Money is only considered taxable income when it is withdrawn from the plan. Each retirement plan has its own rules regarding trading access, which can affect what transactions are possible online.
For many retirees, the instinct during a market downturn is to withdraw funds for immediate cash needs. However, this approach can lead to significant tax liabilities, as any withdrawal is taxed as ordinary income for that tax year. Unlike a temporary dip in the market, which may recover over time, the tax implications of a large withdrawal can be permanent and financially burdensome.
To avoid being forced into a position of selling during market downturns or technical issues, experts recommend that retirees keep a cash reserve equivalent to about two years' worth of expenses, approximately $40,000 in this case, within their 401(k) plans. Additionally, having a backup communication method, such as a phone app, can provide access during website outages.
Decisions regarding 401(k) plans are often made infrequently but carry long-term implications. Critical choices include when to roll over funds, what investments to maintain within the plan, and the timing of withdrawals. To assist retirees in navigating these complex decisions, financial services firm Fisher Investments has made available a resource titled "401k & IRA Tips and Answers," which provides guidance on rollovers, contribution limits, required withdrawals, and more.
In summary, while the Schwab website outage may have initially seemed like a setback for the retiree, it potentially saved him from incurring significant losses by selling during a downturn. Understanding the nuances of retirement account management and tax implications can help retirees make informed decisions that align with their long-term financial objectives.