This Stock Market Selloff Could Block the Fed’s Rate Hikes
The S&P 500 experienced a significant decline on Friday, dropping 3.70% to close at 6,910.39, marking its seventh consecutive loss. Over the week, the index saw an 8.4% decrease, its steepest drop since early April 2025. Similarly, the Nasdaq Composite fell by 5.28% to 22,617.73, putting it in negative territory for the year 2026.
This downturn prompts investors holding the State Street SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust (NYSEARCA:SPY) or the Invesco QQQ Trust (NASDAQ:QQQ) to reconsider the Federal Reserve's monetary policy. In September, the Fed raised its target interest rate range to a maximum of 4.00%, and indications suggest that further increases may still be on the horizon.
Peter Boockvar, the chief investment officer at OnePoint BFG Wealth Partners, commented on the selloff, particularly noting the downturn in AI technology stocks alongside falling prices for industrial metals, oil, and fuel. He expressed doubt about the Fed raising rates again after December if the current market conditions persist, stating, "if they even do then." Boockvar emphasized that he believes Fed Chair Kevin Warsh is aware of these dynamics, but he feels some of Warsh's colleagues may not fully grasp the implications of the current situation. He indicated that the potential for a December rate hike hinges on whether the selloff continues, which will significantly influence investor sentiment leading up to the meeting.
The crux of Boockvar's argument lies in the relationship between the AI sector and the broader economy. He posits that spending on data centers contributes to roughly half of U.S. GDP growth. Additionally, he estimates that AI accounts for about 50% of the market value of the S&P 500 and approximately 75% of its earnings growth. If these estimates hold true, a decline in AI stock prices could adversely affect the economy in two significant ways: companies might reduce their data center expenditures, and consumers could feel financially constrained. This concentration in AI-related stocks also underscores the importance of suppliers that provide power, cooling, and networking for data centers, which are detailed in a complimentary report on AI infrastructure.
Boockvar further highlighted that affluent consumers rely on the stock market for their wealth, and a reduction in their portfolio values could lead to decreased spending, which in turn would slow growth and inflation without the Fed needing to intervene. The drop in prices of metals and fuel could additionally contribute to a decrease in inflation rates.
In the bond market, traders have already adjusted their expectations. The yield on the 2-year Treasury, which is closely aligned with Fed rate expectations, fell to 4.63% on Friday, down from 4.88% the previous week. This decline included a notable drop of 13 basis points on Friday alone, mirroring the decrease observed in early September 2024. Meanwhile, the 10-year Treasury yield decreased from 5.15% to 4.92%. Despite these shifts, the CME FedWatch tool still indicated a 92% likelihood of a quarter-point rate hike in December. The falling yield of the 2-year Treasury suggests that traders anticipate fewer hikes beyond December.
A report from Citi on Friday noted that the markets are reflecting concerns that current interest rates may be too high given the declining stock valuations and the increasing risk of reduced AI investments. The bank maintained its expectation for a quarter-point hike in December, arguing that the Fed aims to preserve its credibility regarding inflation. Following that, Citi anticipates the Fed will hold rates steady and potentially begin cutting them later in 2027, a trajectory consistent with its earlier forecasts.
Lawrence Gillum from LPL Financial remarked that if the AI selloff results in tighter financial conditions, the Fed might choose to slow down and reassess its approach. However, this view contrasts with that of Fed Governor Lisa Cook, who asserted that financial conditions remain overly accommodating and that a single rate hike in September is unlikely to suffice.
QQQ has been particularly vulnerable, having fallen 14.8% in the past month compared to SPY's 9.8% decline. A significant portion of QQQ's holdings consists of chipmakers and related equipment companies, with its largest position accounting for about 7.6% of net assets as of June. Currently, QQQ has increased by just 0.58% this year, while SPY has risen by 2.26%. The VIX index, which closed at 28.44 on Thursday, is nearing the 30 mark, typically associated with heightened market fear.
For investors in SPY and QQQ, the implications of the selloff are noteworthy. SPY's diversified holdings across various sectors offer some insulation from the AI sector's volatility, while QQQ's performance is more directly influenced by AI trends. Should the Fed halt rate increases after December, QQQ may rebound more sharply than SPY due to lower yields benefiting growth stocks; however, if apprehensions surrounding AI spending persist, QQQ could face further declines, as indicated by its more pronounced recent losses. Short-term Treasuries would also benefit from a pause in rate hikes, as their prices would rise with falling yields.
Trading will resume on Monday, November 23, with the Fed set to announce its decision on December 9. Boockvar's analysis suggests that if the Fed raises rates and signals a hold for 2027, the case for a swift recovery in SPY may weaken if stock prices continue to decline.